Dave’s Insanity Sauce: Scoville Heat, Ingredients and Bottles to Buy

This page contains affiliate links. See our Affiliate Disclosure for details.

šŸ”„ Single Sauce

Dave’s Gourmet gives Dave’s Insanity Sauce a heat level of “INSANELY HOT” and no Scoville number. The figure that follows it around is 180,000, from PepperScale and from Wikipedia, which cites Fox News; PepperScale doesn’t say who rated it. Dave’s own ingredient list puts hot pepper extract fourth, right behind hot peppers, water and tomato paste, and SeƱor Pants reads that as the reason Dave’s says to add it a drop at a time.

Updated November 2026

Dave’s Insanity on Amazon

BottleSizePer ouncePriceGet it
Dave’s Insanity, single bottle5 oz$2.60$12.99One bottle of Insanity ($12.99)
Dave’s Insanity, 3-pack3 x 5 oz$1.33$19.90Three bottles, about half per ounce ($19.90)
Dave’s Insanity Super Hot 4-pack4 x 5 oz: Insanity, Ghost Pepper, Scorpion, Carolina Reaper$2.00$39.99The four-sauce crate ($39.99)

SeƱor Pants’ pick

Buy the 3-pack for a house that already goes through hot sauce: per ounce it costs about half what the single does. For a one-time dare, the single 5-ounce bottle is plenty, since Dave’s says to add it one drop at a time and 5 ounces is a lot of drops. The 4-pack crate puts Insanity next to Dave’s Ghost, Scorpion and Reaper bottles.

Dave's Gourmet Original Insanity Hot Sauce, 5 oz bottle

Hotter than the Hot Ones Da Bomb, half a Mad Dog

On that 180,000 estimate, Insanity runs 36 to 72 times hotter than Tabasco Original, which Tabasco rates at 2,500 to 5,000. It lands above Beyond Insanity, the Da Bomb on Hot Ones, which Spicin Foods rates at 135,600, and at about half of Mad Dog 357 Original’s 357,000. On the hottest hot sauce chart it sits between those two bottles.

Dave’s recommends Insanity for “Original Chileheads.” On Dave’s site its Ghost Pepper sauce climbs to “INSANELY HOT +” and the Carolina Reaper bottle to “INSANELY HOT + +”, which puts Insanity below both on Dave’s own labels.

Dave’s direction, on its own page and on Amazon: add it one drop at a time. Its suggested targets are stews, burgers and burritos. Keep the Frank’s-sized pours for Frank’s.

Three ingredient lists for one sauce

Dave’s site and two Amazon listings disagree on the recipe:

WhereIngredients, as listed
davesgourmet.comHot peppers, water, tomato paste, hot pepper extract, cane vinegar, salt, onions, garlic, citric and acetic acids, xanthan gum, spices
Amazon, single 5 ozTomato sauce, onions, hot pepper extract, hot peppers, vinegar, spices, soy oil, garlic, salt
Amazon, 3-packRed habanero, hot pepper extract, red chilies, tomato paste, salt, onions, cane vinegar, acetic acid, garlic, vegetable oil, xanthan gum, citric acid

Anyone avoiding soy should read the bottle that arrives. Dave’s page says the sauce “contains no known allergens,” yet the single’s Amazon listing names soy oil, and the 3-pack’s names an unspecified vegetable oil, while Dave’s own list has no oil at all. Hot pepper extract makes the top four on all three lists, and tomato appears on all three. Only the 3-pack list names habanero. As far as the Super Hot 4-pack listing shows, its Insanity line opens the same way as Dave’s site.

“Banned,” according to Dave’s

Dave Hirschkop’s Insanity Sauce premiered around 1993, per Wikipedia, as one of the first sauces made with capsaicin extract. Dave’s product page calls it “the original hottest sauce in the universe” and “the only sauce ever banned from the National Fiery Food Show”; those are the maker’s words, and SeƱor Pants is happy to let them stand as a dare. Dave’s site and the single bottle’s Amazon title both note its Hot Ones appearance in Season 1.

FAQ

Is Dave’s Insanity hotter than Da Bomb?

Yes for Beyond Insanity at 135,600, going by the estimated 180,000. Da Bomb’s Ground Zero (321,900) and The Final Answer (1.5 million) are both hotter, per Spicin Foods. The Da Bomb review covers all four Da Bomb bottles.

Which Dave’s sauce is hotter, Insanity, Ghost Pepper or Carolina Reaper?

Dave’s site gives each a heat label, and the labels climb from Insanity to Ghost Pepper to Carolina Reaper. The Ghost Pepper bottle is ranked on the ghost pepper guide and the Reaper bottle on the Carolina Reaper guide; both score lower there for their added extract.

Where does Dave’s Insanity sell for less?

Dave’s own site lists the single bottle for less than Amazon does, but on November 15, 2026 it showed sold out, as did Dave’s 3-pack, which lists higher than Amazon’s (Dave’s gives no bottle size). On Amazon, the 3-pack is the better buy per ounce.

Where these facts come from

The ingredient list, heat labels, serving direction and marketing claims come from Dave’s Gourmet’s product pages on davesgourmet.com. The Amazon ingredient lists, sizes and prices come from the three Amazon listings, and the drop-at-a-time direction from the single bottle’s listing. Dave’s pages were read on November 12, 2026, and its store status and all three Amazon listings were checked again on November 15, 2026. The 180,000 figure is PepperScale’s and Wikipedia’s (citing Fox News), and the launch around 1993 is Wikipedia’s. Tabasco’s range is Tabasco’s own, as recorded on the everyday Scoville chart. The Da Bomb figures are Spicin Foods’ and the Mad Dog 357 figure is Ashley Food Company’s, as recorded on the Da Bomb review and the Mad Dog 357 page. SeƱor Pants ran no lab tests and records no tasting.